Human Wreckage True Crime

A Teen, A Murder, And A Neighborhood Torn Apart: Edward O'Brien Jr

• Thomas W

Share episode
SPEAKER_00:

Welcome to Human Wreckage, the podcast that explores the darkest corners of human nature, where ordinary lives are shattered by unimaginable violence, and the line between reality and nightmare disappears. Today's episode takes us to the quiet streets of Somerville, Massachusetts, a close knit neighborhood just outside Boston, where in the summer of 1995 an unspeakable act of brutality would forever alter the lives of two families and leave a community searching for answers. This is the story of Edward O'Brien Jr., a well liked fifteen year old high school sophomore. Smart, charming, athletic, the kind of kid you wouldn't look at twice, except maybe to say, that boy's going places. But on july twenty third, nineteen ninety five, the mass dropped. That afternoon, forty two year old Janet Downing, a mother of four and the single parent of O'Brien's close friend, was found brutally stabbed to death in her home. Her body was discovered by her teenage sons, her blood staining the walls and floors of the house where she had tried to raise her family in peace. The attack was frenzied, vicious, overkill. She had been stabbed nearly one hundred times. At first, investigators were baffled. There was no forced entry. Nothing stolen, no known enemies, just a trail of blood, and a teenage boy with wounds on his hands, a strange explanation, and more than a few secrets. Within hours, suspicion turned toward Edward O'Brien junior, the boy next door, the best friend of Janet's son, but no one wanted to believe it. How could a fifteen year old commit such a savage, calculated murder? How could someone so young be capable of that level of violence? As police pieced together the evidence, what emerged was a chilling portrait of a teen with a dark imagination, a fascination with knives and perhaps a hidden rage no one had seen coming. This wasn't just a murder. It was a rupture in the fabric of a neighborhood, a crime so shocking that it would spark national headlines and a courtroom battle over whether a child should be tried as an adult for the ultimate crime. Tonight we'll explore what happened in that quiet Somerville home. We'll trace Edward O'Brien's descent into infamy, revisit the trial that tested the limits of juvenile justice, and ask, What really turns a teenager into a killer? This is human wreckage, and this is the story of Edward O'Brien Junior. rushed to the vehicle to carry the grocery bags inside. Standing at six feet four inches and weighing two hundred sixty pounds, Edward was described by the locals as a gentle giant. He was a former altar boy that loved sports. It started out as a typical Sunday. It was a scorching hot summer's afternoon and Janet had done the grocery shopping and stopped to chat to her neighbor. They spoke of the shock of the recent unsolved murder of seventeen year old Deanna Kremen. Little did they know that in just several hours another murder would take place in their city. Janet decided to take a nap after putting the groceries away. Ryan and Edward had planned on going to the local swimming pool that afternoon. Why is your mother sleeping? Edward inquired as he stood staring at Janet. Ryan shrugged and said, Let's go swimming. Edward decided against going swimming and the duel went their separate ways. Some peculiar occurrences had been happening in Janet's home over the past several months. Items appeared and then disappeared including her favorite Christmas decorations and her daughter's house keys. Someone put perfume in her coffee, put windshield wiper fluid in her car, and left a bag of clothing in her closet. It wouldn't be until ten PM later on that night that Ryan came home from swimming and hanging out with his friends. He was met by an unforgettable scene. At some point between Ryan leaving the house and returning, somebody had entered their family home and brutally murdered his mother. Janet had been slashed and stabbed over ninety times. Blood was spattered all across the room and across the family photographs. Ryan ran across the street to Edward's home and told his parents to call the police. Edward O'Brien Sr. ran to the Downing family home after calling the police, assuming that some kind of accident had taken place. He realized straight away that he was in the middle of a gruesome crime scene and that this certainly was no accident. Who could do such a thing, he wondered. Within days, however, his own son would be charged with the murder. As police were rushing to the crime scene, Edward Jr. walked to the store where he worked part-time. He told the manager that he had been mugged and slashed with a knife by muggers who he said were African American or Hispanic. He was reluctant to call the police, but the manager persuaded him. His hand was sliced up pretty severely, and he had fresh scratches and blood on his legs. When police arrived to take Edward's statement in regards to the so called mugging, they became immediately suspicious. The area Edward claimed he had been mugged was a highly trafficked area, yet nobody saw a thing. They became even more suspicious when Edward recited his address. Three friends of Edward and Ryan came forward to recollect that they had gone to Ryan's house that night, but received no answer at the door. They stated that they heard loud noises coming from the backyard. When they went to investigate, they found Edward crouching in the bushes. They said he glanced and smiled at them before calmly walking away without saying a word. According to investigators, they found Edward's fingerprints and blood on the front door, as well as on a wooden post in the cellar. In addition, a knife hilt found in Janet's home matched a knife owned by Edward that they later found in the trash. When Edward was arrested and charged with Janet's murder, he was unnaturally cool. There was absolutely nothing coming out of him. Nothing, no fear, no screaming, I didn't do this. Nothing in any way that resembled what you might expect out of a fifteen year old kid who's being charged with cutting up his best friend's mother. His eyes were black. Nothing there, it made my blood run cold. Recalled Middlesex County District Attorney Tom Riley. While Edward initially claimed that he hadn't been in the Dowling home on the night of the murder, when presented with the evidence that placed him at the scene, he changed his story. He then claimed that he had encountered a masked man over the body of Janet and that the man threatened to kill him if he told anybody about what he had seen. Edward was tried as an adult due to the horrific nature of the crime and an ambitious district attorney, Thomas Riley. During his trial, it was theorized that Edward killed Janet because he had developed a sexual obsession with her. According to Riley, Edward used a telescope to watch Janet undress from across the street. He also asserted that he was fascinated with violence. Edward refused to testify at trial. Edward O'Brien Jr. was found guilty and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole. The jury had deliberated for eight hours before deciding that Edward used extreme cruelty and atrocity when he killed Janet. As the sentence was read aloud, his father gasped, Oh my God, but Edward showed no emotion. As he was led from the courtroom, his father shouted, We know you're innocent, we love you. According to Edward's family, Janet's brother in law, Artie Ortiz, was the real killer. She was afraid of Artie Ortiz. He murdered her, shouted Edward's mother Trisha, following the verdict. You're a liar, you're a liar, screamed Janet's daughter, Carrie Ann Downing. Ortiz and his wife had lived with Janet. However, four months before her murder, Janet kicked them out after she discovered that Ortiz had been dealing drugs out of the home. Apparently, he refused to return his keys. Ortiz was never even considered a suspect in Janet's murder. According to Middlesex County District Attorney Thomas Riley, there was never any evidence pointing towards him being guilty, but a profusion pointing towards Edward. It's a terrible injustice that has been done by even bringing in a man who is totally innocent into this case by injecting his name into this case, he said. Trisha told people that Edward was a scapegoat. She contended that Ortiz's cab was towed from their street on the night of the murder with a trail of blood beside it. However, police stated that the blood was Edward's and the cab was towed because Ortiz lost his keys in the confusion of the murder. Make no sense about it, it was the evidence that convicted Edward O'Brien, said Riley. In the book, The Politics of Murder, Margot Nash, a trial attorney assigned by the court to be Edward's guardian, highlighted some of the evidence which she claimed pointed towards Edward being innocent and Ortiz guilty. The attack was so vicious that there was blood across the stairs and walls pooling at the floor. However, Edward had no blood on him. The prosecutor decided against identifying the DNA under Janet's fingernails, as well as other DNA and fingerprints at the scene. Gina Mahoney, a neighbor, had seen Ortiz entering Janet's home when she was out several times in the past. Furthermore, before her murder, Janet had expressed her fears about Ortiz. When Mahoney asked to speak to investigators, they declined her attempts to be interviewed. They also refused to speak to Virginia Recly, who had apparently heard a commotion at a point during the short time window when the murder could have taken place, but when witnesses had established that Edward was elsewhere. While the evidence against Edward may have been compelling at the time, the crime scene had not been adequately secured for several hours, and while more is known about forensic science nowadays that may have raised reasonable doubts in a jury's mind. In 2013, a ruling by the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court ruled that juveniles convicted of murder serving a mandatory life sentence should have a chance at parole, meaning Edward's case could go up for review. However, to be eligible for parole, Edward would have to confess to the crime. Since he professes his innocence, that is something he is not willing to do. Edward O'Brien Jr. was convicted of the murder of Janet Downing in 1996. He was sixteen years old when the trial began in seventeen when the verdict came down, guilty of first degree murder. He's now serving a life sentence without the possibility of parole. To the prosecution, it was an open and shut case. The wounds on his hands, the DNA evidence. The knife was allegedly found in his room a violent crime. A violent boy, case closed. But if you look closer, the story starts to shift. The forensic evidence was circumstantial. The so called murder weapon wasn't conclusively tied to the crime. His wounds, they could be consistent with defensive injuries or with something else entirely. And despite the brutality of the attack, no physical evidence definitively placed O'Brien inside the crime scene at the time of the murder. There was no confession, no witnesses, no clear motive, just a string of inferences and a growing pressure to find someone to blame. He was a teenager with a dark imagination and a growing interest in knives. But does that make him a killer? Some people say yes, others aren't so sure. Supporters of O'Brien, including members of his family and a small group of legal advocates, have continued to raise questions about how the investigation was handled and whether confirmation bias led police to build a case around him instead of following the evidence wherever it led. Was justice truly served? Or did the system fail a fifteen year old boy and a murdered mother by settling for the most convenient answer? Janet Downing's family deserves truth. Edward O'Brien deserves it too, because the horrifying reality is this, if he didn't do it, the real killer has never been caught. In the end, this case leaves us with a haunting uncertainty about guilt, innocence, and the fragile line between the two. Thanks for joining us on Human Wreckage. If you found this episode unsettling, good, so did we. Follow us for more true crime stories that challenge what we think we know about human nature and the wreckage we leave behind.